Menu and Pricing

Feel free to ask about custom orders or other requests. Items must be picked up in Lynnwood. I do not deliver.

To place an order, please message me at myrumblytumbly@gmail.com or on Facebook.

A note about Thanksgiving 2021….

I am almost sold out for Thanksgiving. I am offering a set menu, listed below. To place an order, please send me a message on Facebook or at myrumblytumbly@gmail.com

Pies

My pies are made fresh for the day of pick up. I use organic dairy products and free range, pasture raised eggs. I always use fresh seasonal produce when available. Since homemade pie crust is my jam, you can always expect a flaky, delicious, homemade crust.  Most double crust pies can be made with a crumb topping if desired.  Add a cinnamon roll top or bottom crust to any pie for $5.

43045423_2130590676974903_9040616733118824448_n

Personalized Pies: $3 additional
{I can add a message, sentiment, or movie quote to any double crusted pie below.}


9509A83A-14E5-4F71-9A76-31C36CD9DAEC-11496-0000098F3E2B9150

Strawberry Rhubarb: $30
{Tart rhubarb and sweet strawberries in a flaky homemade lattice crust.}

8C920AC5-AF19-439F-A072-D0C5A62596F6

Patriotic Pie: $35
{Taking pre-orders for July 4th.  Tart montmorency cherries for the red and sweet fresh blueberries for the blue.  Baked in my flaky homemade pie crust.  *I can do this pie in any flavor if you don’t care about color.}

Lemon Raspberry Cream: $30
{Buttery graham cracker crust with a creamy lemon filling, swirled with raspberry coulis, and topped with whipped cream, more raspberry coulis, and lemon slices}

Pumpkin Pie: $25
{Homemade flaky pie crust, with smooth, creamy, sweet, and perfectly spiced pumpkin filling.   Jazz this pie up further with a cinnamon roll crust for $5 additional.}

Chocolate Chess Pie with Espresso Whipped Cream: $30
{My FAVORITE of all my chocolate pies! This pie has classic flaky crust, but the filling is the real star. Real Lindt chocolate bars, heavy cream, eggs, and butter are combined to make this incredibly rich and decadent pie. And I top the whole thing off with Espresso whipped cream, Lindt chocolate bars, and chocolate covered espresso beans. *regular whipped cream available upon request.}

Vegan Pumpkin Pie: $28
{Homemade vegan flaky pie crust, with smooth, creamy, sweet, and perfectly spiced pumpkin filling.  Made with coconut milk and no butter, eggs, milk, or dairy.  Jazz this pie up further with a cinnamon roll crust (as pictured) for $5 additional.}

Key Lime Pie: $25
{One of my most popular pies. Buttery graham cracker crust with a tart but sweet perfect key lime filling, topped with whipped cream and key lime zest.}

Raspberry Key Lime Pie: $30
{A new offering.  Buttery graham cracker crust with a tart but sweet perfect key lime filling, swirled with homemade raspberry puree, topped with whipped cream, lime, and raspberry puree.}

Mixed Berry Pie

Mixed Berry Pie: $25
{A mix of blackberries, blueberries, and raspberries in a homemade flaky pie crust. Also available in a crumble topping.}

Grasshopper Pie: $30
{Oreo cookie crust filled with smooth, homemade lindt chocolate pudding filling, and topped with a peppermint whipped cream and Andes mints.}

lemon pie 1

Lemon Pie: $25
{a sweet yet tart lemon pie, baked in the most perfect, buttery, slightly salted graham cracker crust and topped with whipped cream.}

IMG_9944

Lemon Pie with Fresh Fruit: $25
{a sweet yet tart lemon pie, baked in the most perfect, buttery, slightly salted graham cracker crust and topped with fresh strawberries, lemons, and mint.}

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie by Rumbly in my Tumbly

Peanut Butter Pie: $30
{Oreo cookie crust, filled with smooth peanut butter filling and topped with rich chocolate ganache and peanut butter cups. A chocolate peanut butter lovers dream.}

Apple Crumb Pie: $25
{One of my most popular pies. Flaky pie crust, filled with tart granny smith apples, cinnamon, sugar, and topped with the most delicious crumble ever.}

fullsizeoutput_d99

Strawberry Cream Pie: $27
{The most buttery and delicious graham cracker crust, filled with a stabilized whipped cream and cream cheese filling, a touch of lemon, and topped with delicious, sweet, homemade strawberry jam. *can also be made with homemade raspberry, blueberry, or blackberry jam if preferred.}

Cinnamon Roll Apple Pie: $30
{my classic homemade apple pie, with a twist- a Cinnamon roll top crust.  My homemade flaky pie crust is swirled with butter, cinnamon, and brown sugar.  It’s amazing.}

IMG_5352

Coconut Cream Pie: $25
{My homemade flaky pie crust filled with creamy, homemade vanilla pudding and toasted coconut, topped with sweetened coconut flakes — the customer who ordered this pie asked for blueberries on top. Usually, it’s just coconut.}

Raspberry Cream Pie

Raspberry Cream: $27
{flaky, homemade crust, stabilized whipped cream with a touch of cream cheese, topped with raspberry coulis}

Pecan: $27
{A classic with toasted pecans, brown sugar, vanilla, butter and a touch of cinnamon.}

Chocolate Pecan: $27
{A classic with toasted pecans, brown sugar, vanilla, butter, semisweet chocolate, and a touch of cinnamon.}

Berry Crumb Pie: $25
{Flaky pie crust, filled with a mixture of blackberries and raspberries, a touch of cinnamon, sugar, and topped with the most delicious crumble ever.}

Lemon Meringue Pie: $25
{Flaky pie crust filled with sweet lemon curd and topped with light and fluffy toasted meringue.}

Peach Pie: $25 (Seasonal, usually June-October)
{My favorite seasonal pie! Flaky, buttery crust with never frozen, fresh yellow peaches, and a touch of cinnamon. Available in crumb topping as well.

apple berry pie

Apple Berry Pie: $25
{Apple pie mixed with raspberries or blackberries, cinnamon, and sugar in a delicious, flaky homemade crust.}

Good Ol’ Fashioned Homemade Apple: $25
{flaky homemade pie crust, filled with granny smith apples and loads of cinnamon. Also available with a crumble topping.}

Death by Chocolate: $30
{4 times the chocolate! chocolate Oreo crust, homemade chocolate custard with fresh eggs and whole milk, fresh homemade chocolate whipped cream, and chocolate drizzle.}

Blueberry Pie: $25
{Sweet blueberries in a regular or lattice homemade flaky pie crust. Also available with a crumble topping.}

Shortbread Lemon Tart

Lemon Tart: $30
{thick and buttery shortbread crust filled with perfect homemade lemon curd and dusted with powdered sugar.}

Chocolate Cream Pie: $27
{homemade chocolate custard with fresh eggs and whole milk, fresh homemade whipped cream, and chocolate chocolate shavings. Available in classic flaky pie crust or oreo cookie crust}

Banana Cream Pie: $27
{fresh sliced bananas, homemade vanilla pudding made with fresh eggs and whole milk, and fresh homemade whipped cream in a graham cracker crust. Also available in flaky, classic crust.}

20150812_165404

Blackberry Pie: $25
{flaky homemade lattice crust filled with sweet blackberries.  Heaven with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.}

5FBC452D-DCE3-4B1B-831A-D16DE4292949

Cherry Pie: $30
{Tart montmorency cherries in a homemade flaky pie crust.  Also available with a crumble topping.}

Gluten Free Pies: $40
{most of my classic crust pies can be made gluten-free, using King Arthur Flour gf flour. This dough is much harder to work with and cannot be personalized.}

Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie: $25
{If it looks like a pie, and comes in a pie box, we can cal this gigantic, soft chocolate chip cookie a “pie!”}

Classic Cheesecake: $40
{the most smooth, creamy cheesecake, baked to perfection in a slightly salted graham cracker crust. Add a homemade strawberry, raspberry, or blackberry coulis for $5 additional.}